Not All Engagement Is Created Equal

Here’s What Actually Builds Brand Resonance.

There’s a difference between a post that blows up and a brand that people build their lives around.

In a world that glorifies likes, shares, saves, and swipe-ups, it’s easy to think that virality is the goal. That if you just hit the algorithm jackpot, you’re set.

Virality is nothing more than attention. Resonance is relationship, and that is goals.

And while attention fades, relationships are what keep your business alive.

The Engagement Illusion

Everyone loves a screenshot-worthy spike in engagement. But here’s the trap:

Engagement is not the same as connection.

You can get a comment and still be forgotten 3 seconds later. You can trend without being trusted. You can go viral and still be invisible where it counts, inside people’s real lives (and wallets).

And the numbers back it up:

  • A recent Sprout Social report found that while 80% of marketers track engagement metrics obsessively, only 30% said they felt those metrics actually reflect brand health.
  • A Medallia/Ipsos survey of CX professionals highlights that 86% agree customer loyalty is growing in strategic importance, and 97% say it directly impacts overall business success. And building real loyalty offline still pays off: consumers are more likely to stick with brands they repeatedly experience—purchase more after loyalty benefits kick in, and stay loyal even when prices rise.

Let that sink in. People trust people. Not the post. Not the likes. Not your polished, punchy carousel.The relationship matters more than the reach.


Engagement ≠ Alignment

Let’s go deeper. Someone liking your post doesn’t mean they like your brand. They might like the aesthetic. The sass. The trend. But will they buy from you? Refer you? Ride for you when the algorithm shifts?According to the Edelman Trust Barometer, 64% of consumers say they buy from brands that share their values. Not the ones with the most polished grid or viral Reel.

That takes something different: alignment.

Alignment is when your values match theirs. When your brand feels like home, not a performance.

It’s built when:

  • Your founder’s story makes someone cry a little in their coworking space
  • Your mission echoes something your audience already believes in their bones
  • Your off-screen experiences feel just as good as your curated feed

Alignment creates belonging. And belonging builds brands that last.

Virality Is a Sugar High. Community Is the Slow Burn.

The pressure to stay “relevant” online is real. But relevance without resonance is just noise.

What happens when your viral moment passes? When the trend shifts? When your “social media manager” quits and takes your whole personality with them?That’s when we see brands spiral. Because they never had roots, just reach.

What to Build Instead

1. Build with your community, not for the algorithm.
Talk to real humans. Start conversations. Show up where your people already are (hint: not just on your grid).

2. Make your offline brand as strong as your online one.
From packaging to pop-ups to partnerships, resonance happens in the details people feel, not just the ones they scroll past.

3. Treat clarity like currency.
Trends may catch the eye, but truth holds attention. Say what you mean. Stand for something. Say it again.

4. Remember: consistency > virality.
You don’t need to blow up. You need to show up. Over time. In ways that build trust, not just traction.


Our Take?
Anyone can post. But not everyone builds presence.

Previous

Next